Search
Login
Register

State Superintendent Watkins resigns

Rift spotlights governor, board, union

Mon., April 11, 2005

On Jan. 29, Michigan Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Watkins resigned, ending an unusually public and acrimonious conflict between Gov. Jennifer Granholm and the state Board of Education over Watkins’ leadership.

Debate over Watkins’ ability to head the Department of Education marked the final weeks of his tenure. The governor’s office stated in the Detroit Free Press on Jan. 19 that Watkins was "not providing effective leadership in one of the most critical departments in state government." In the same article, Gov. Granholm claimed, "(Watkins) needs to resign for the good of the state board, for the good of public education." She said her disapproval of Watkins’ work had been known to him for months.

However, Booth Newspapers reported on Jan. 12 that Granholm had given Watkins a letter of praise for a July (2004) performance evaluation. The state board, which had hired Watkins, had recently awarded him a job evaluation of "A-."

Among the events which transpired from July 2004 to January 2005 was a difference of opinion between Watkins and the Michigan Education Association. According to a letter sent to Watkins from the MEA on Oct. 4, 2004, Watkins chose not to withhold funds from a Bay Mills Community College charter school after having done so in April 2003 due to questions of legality. The MEA was opposed to this charter school receiving state funds because the union contended that Bay Mills charters could not be considered public schools.

The October MEA letter to Watkins states: "As the Superintendent of Public Instruction you have a legal duty to ensure that academies are legally authorized and are adequately supervised by a public body … If you feel you need more statutory authority, and more funding, we will support your efforts to achieve such within the Legislature."

The Department of Education had previously been given the green light to disburse funds to Bay Mills charters after Gov. Granholm’s legal division determined it was indeed legal to do so.

In December, another point of contention between Watkins and the MEA developed when Watkins released a controversial school-funding report offering ideas about reforms to Michigan’s education system. His untraditional approach to solving the "Structural Issues Surrounding Michigan School Funding In the 21st Century" may have raised some eyebrows.

In his report, Watkins challenged some widely-held views within the education community: "A simple solution would be to join the chorus that simply asks for more tax revenue to fund our schools. … However, solely funding the current system will not yield the results our children need and deserve." The report goes on to say: "Boldness and candor are required to identify the challenges as well as to make recommendations that address them. The primary postulate, that additional revenue without unprecedented change in the fundamental structure of our public education system is not enough, is not widely agreed to by the education populace" (Watkins’ emphasis).

Watkins’ troubles were not limited to disagreements with the MEA or fallout from the December report. He attracted attention with comments published in a Jan. 2 Grand Rapids Press story on charter schools. In the article, MEA Communications Director Margaret Trimer-Hartley stated that she believed the progress of charter schools was inconclusive, and that she was concerned about stories of charter schools discouraging special education students from enrolling. Watkins responded bluntly: "Does some of it happen? Sure. But let’s take a look at traditional schools. Some of them will complain about losing 300 (students) to a charter, but you won’t hear a peep out of them when 3,000 (dropouts) go to the streets."

On Jan. 11, four weeks after the Watkins report was released and nine days after his Grand Rapids Press comments, "Dozens of educators and parents packed a state board meeting to praise Watkins for his ‘call to action,’" reported Booth Newspapers Lansing Bureau. The governor offered a tepid endorsement of Watkins on the same day, refusing to say anything other than him being a "valued member" of her cabinet.

The board itself was split in their support for Watkins. Board Vice President John Austin, D-Ann Arbor, told Gongwer News Service: "I personally for several years thought we could do better, somebody who was more effective. We now have four of us who see a long pattern of things we would have wanted Tom to have done differently." But, Board President Kathleen Strauss, one of Austin’s fellow Democrats, never wavered in her support of Watkins, according to Gongwer: "She saw Mr. Watkins as both a cheerleader for education and a leader for the department. And she said she still had backing on that from other members of the board."

The board, however, voted to table an extension to Watkins’ contract.

Speculation over the reasons for Watkins’ fall from grace was widespread. Writing for the Oakland Press on Jan. 14, Lansing political commentator Tim Skubick offered one explanation for Granholm’s insistence that Watkins leave his post, "Rightly or wrongly, here’s the knock on Watkins: He is great with the sound bite about moving children up the education ladder, but his depth of expertise is the proverbial mile long and a silly millimeter deep."

On Jan. 19, the Free Press reported that Granholm education adviser Chuck Wilbur said, "Watkins has wrongly suggested that Granholm was perturbed by (the) Dec. 6 report on the plight of schools." Wilbur continued, "It has to do with the way he managed the department."

Watkins responded to criticisms against him on Jan. 20 in a letter to the governor. Claiming he was "inappropriately criticized," Watkins wrote that he was "surprised and perplexed" at Granholm’s turn against him: "Neither you nor any of your staff have shared these concerns with me personally." Watkins asserted that all of Granholm’s comments toward him had been positive, the only exception being in regard to a diagram in Watkins’ December report. He stated, "You said ‘you were furious’ regarding the … funding illustration … that shows that almost 2/3s of new dollars invested in our schools will be used to cover pension and health care expenses."

Watkins also urged Granholm to "direct members of your staff to cease bullying members of the statewide-elected state Board of Education to sell out their conviction and their support of me."

Highlighting further alleged injustices, Watkins hinted at a possible MEA connection though he did not give names. "I have been told that you have asked special interest groups to discredit me and convince my supporters on the State Board to fire me, as a ‘personal favor,’" he wrote.

Watkins maintained that having been successful in private business and in managing the multi-million dollar Department of Mental Health, his administrative and leadership skills could not be called into question.

As for the MEA’s continuing opposition to the Bay Mills charter schools, the union has filed a lawsuit against the superintendent of public instruction, the state Board of Education, and the state treasurer to stop the funding of Bay Mills charter schools. The suit, dated February 3, 2005, was filed days after Watkins’ resignation. Stated explicitly in the complaint is an account of another confrontation between the MEA and Watkins over Bay Mills, occurring only one month after Watkins’ office received the original letter in October. In this subsequent contact, Watkins continued to hold his ground, again deciding not to withhold funds.

The state Board of Education has chosen Jeremy Hughes, Michigan’s chief academic officer, to be acting superintendent until a new permanent superintendent can be appointed. A set of selection criteria has been developed by the board, and they have decided to accept applications until April 8th.

Michigan Education Daily
"National teachers' unions have been solidly behind health care reform so far, but Education Week reports that they are not so excited about a Senate version that would tax so-called "Cadillac" health plans." >>
"Hillsdale Community Schools is offering severance packages to teachers and support personnel who retire now as a way to save money in the long run." >>
"The University of Michigan believes that a plan to create a single health insurance pool for all public employees is unconstitutional, firefighters believe it's unwise, but the president of Lansing Community College sees it as the right moral choice." >>
"Jackson Public Schools is investigating switching insurance carriers, self-funding or asking all employee groups to agree to higher deductibles and co-pays as ways to spend less on health insurance." >>
"Not yet certain whether they will face a $127 per-pupil cut in December, school administrators are reviewing their choices for dealing with it." >>
"More than one-third of the students who live within Detroit Public Schools boundaries attended a public charter school in 2008-2009." >>
"More than one-third of the students who live within Detroit Public Schools boundaries attended a public charter school in 2008-2009." >>
User Comments
I am a teacher in the same county who is presently trying to quit the union. Like Caldwell, I strongly disagree with the MEA.

This article was timely.

Rob Olson
Pittsford Area Schools

>>
I agree this is a change worth making. I describe some of the uneven effects of the idea on my blog at http://rickolson.blogspot.com/2009/08/statewide-health-insurance-plan-for.html which you may also wish to read.

The devil will be in the details, so this is one we will need to monitor closely.

Rick Olson from Saline, former school Business Manager >>

Nowadays, saving money is very crucial and properly investing the money can keep you and your family away from the effect of the financial crisis. The sad news is that a lot of the options for short term funding have been drying up. Short term funding is a necessary thing to have around, and going through traditional channels such as banks isn't an option for a lot of people anymore – basically it's only open to Ken Lewis. Installment loans are an option, but some people, including senior citizens, have been thinking about raiding their retirement fund. Getting into your pension retirement plan or 401(k) funds is the last thing you want to do if you don't qualify for any withdrawals yet. The penalties are substantial, and you'll end up needing installments loans to pay them if you use retirement funds for <a rev="vote for" title="Installment Loans Reliable Option As 401(k)s are Dwindling" href="http://personalmoneystore.com/moneyblog/2009/05/17/installment-loans-reliable-option-401ks-dwindling/">short term funding</a>.


>>
I AGREE >>
Godfrey-Lee on the west side of the state has been running all-day, every-day kindergarten for several years. >>
We have a problem in Detroit Public School, their system had cash flow problem for years now. And honestly it getting worst in terms in progression with more children leaving to charter their schools almost every year. The state decided to give the Detroit school districts cash advance of $70 million so they would meet the schools expenses, as well as payment for teachers. Robert Bobb, the newly appointed emergency financial manager, requested the funds early in order for him to get the house in order before he had to start panicking. President Obama has been giving out large sums of money for troubled school districts, perhaps that’s where a generous portion of the aid came from. Getting Detroit Public Schools in working order is a worthy cause.

LINK TO READ FOR MORE INFO:
http://personalmoneystore.com/moneyblog/2009/03/10/state-advance-detroit-public-schools-70m/


>>
I am all for school choice and think its great that charters are finally moving forward. However, I'm wondering if the research accounts for a playing field that is not level. I can't take my school buildings and move them anywhere I want, nor can I simply slap up a pole building and make it a school. If anything, public schools need less state regulation and oversight so we can play by the same minimal rules charters do. If you want public schools to compete to improve, remove the barriers to doing so. I will gladly except less funding per pupil if the playing field is level.
>>
The purpose is to encourage non excercising children to excercise but my daughter's highschool gave her an improper body fat percentage and made my healthy daughter who trains 20 hours a week in tap jazz and ballet believe she was overweaghit instead of a person with muscles.
I believe the public schools do not have the right to make the diagnoses with these kids because they are using one measurement and recording it from their arms that they have a certain percetnage of body fat with one arm caliper test.
Does any one have feed back?
>>
Specifically, 81 percent of students in religiously affiliated schools and 82 percent of students in other private schools have parents who report being "very satisfied" with their schools, compared to 55 percent of students in assigned public schools and 63 percent of students in chosen public schools.

High levels of satisfaction among private school parents also extend to opinions about their children's teachers, academic standards of the school, order and discipline at the school, the amount of homework assigned, and interactions with school personnel.

http://fitt.in >>
Treatment centers offer <A HREF=http://www.teenageproblems.net/>struggling children treatment </A> in effective and real sense. Center provides expert and professional medical expertise that have years of treatment experience. Center develops spiritual qualities in youths. They encourage teens to become descent.

http://www.teenageproblems.net/
>>